EDEN SHER: I WAS ON A SITCOM – REVIEW – EDINBURGH FRINGE

I may have come dangerously close to passing out, but this story of Eden Sher’s pregnancy and her reckoning with her time on ‘The Middle’, is incredibly compelling and excellently performed. You can see why it has all but sold out for the rest of its run.

Evident from the beginning of the show is the command that Sher has over the audience. She has a magnetic stage presence that automatically sucks you in, aided by the incredible physicality of her performance. She is also able to excellently play off her audience, giving you a performance that feels almost personalised. 

The actual show itself manages to get just the right balance between serious and lighthearted, which is difficult to achieve given how dark this show goes. For example, as much as I think this is a great show that I would definitely recommend, if you’re in any way squeamish, this might be a show to give a miss (There are no content warnings for it on the Edinburgh Fringe website which feels like a bit of an oversight) because of the pretty graphic descriptions of labour. However, in spite of how dark it gets, the show remains entertaining.

The one aspect of the show that didn’t work so well for me was the integration between the two themes of the show – Sher’s pregnancy, and her relationship with her time on ‘The Middle’. Although there are some points where the two themes intermingle, it felt a little like they’d both make for great individual shows as they didn’t have much in common. This didn’t prove to be a massive problem for the show, mostly because it focuses primarily on the pregnancy theme, the two ideas don’t ever really butt heads. However, it does feel like there’s a second show currently hidden in this one.

Overall, an expertly constructed show with an excellent central performance. Viewers beware if you’re squeamish, but if you’re okay with hospital dramas and you’re up for a good time, this would be a good fit for you.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Find all our Ed Fringe 2023 content here!

Click here to find tickets and info for all Edinburgh Show!

{🎟 AD: PR Invite – Tickets gifted in exchange for an honest review}

2 Star Review 3 Star Review 4 Star Review 5 Star Review 2022 2023 2024 Adaptation Almeida Cabaret Camden Fringe Cast Announcement Christmas Comedy Dance Drag Edinburgh Fringe Edinburgh Fringe Interviews Fringe Immersive Interview Interviews Jukebox Musical LGBTQIA+ Lyric Hammersmith Manchester Musical News New Wimbledon Theatre North West Off West End Park Theatre Play Regional Production Review Revival Richmond Theatre Shakespeare Show Announcement Show Recommendations Soho Theatre Southwark Playhouse Touring Production VAULT Festival West End

  • DAVID HOYLE: STILL GOT IT…? – REVIEW – AVIVA STUDIOS
    Still Got It is the culmination of David Hoyle’s three weekresidency at Aviva Studios, where friends old and new are brought together for a celebration of avant-garde performance art and old school drag. With guest performances from dance troupe the Glitterbomb Dancers and drag queen Veda Lady, Still Got It is a celebration of David Hoyle’s life, his work, and us – who still have it.  The Aviva Studios’ main stage boasts an impressive 1600-person capacity, the size of the stage at times proved to be a challenge for some performers, who are clearly more used to small stages. Hoyle’s own performance was by far the strongest part … More DAVID HOYLE: STILL GOT IT…? – REVIEW – AVIVA STUDIOS
  • PIPPIN IN CONCERT – REVIEW – THEATRE ROYAL DRURY LANE
    Pippin premiered on Broadway in 1972 and in the West End the following year. With music and lyrics by Stephen Schwartz, and a book by Roger O. Hirson, the musical tells the story of Pippin, heir to the throne, as he embarks on a quest to find himself. Now back in London for two nights only, in a concert production directed by Jonathan O’Boyle, which celebrates the show’s 50th anniversary – with an all-star cast. There have been a lot of musical theatre concert productions recently, however this might just be the best one yet. Played with a full orchestra, and a full choir, this joyous score is brought to life … More PIPPIN IN CONCERT – REVIEW – THEATRE ROYAL DRURY LANE
  • RAGE ROOM – REVIEW – TRAVERSE THEATRE
    This review contains spoilers for the show’s ending. I would usually work around this when reviewing, but it is unfortunately key to the discussion of the show and its flaws.  Going to script-in-hand presentations of plays in early stages of development can be a really rewarding experience. Sometimes you get to see a show that, although rough around the edges, is clearly going to become something really special. However, it can mean seeing a show that really does need a lot of development and this was unfortunately the case with Rage Room, a new play by Mhairi Quinn presented as … More RAGE ROOM – REVIEW – TRAVERSE THEATRE
  • INTERVIEW – LUCIE JONES
    Ellie chats to Lucie Jones ahead of her solo concerts at Cadogan Hall this May. Firstly, how are you feeling ahead of your solo concerts at Cadogan Hall this May? I am so excited for these gigs! It feels like I haven’t done a solo show for ages and I have loved choosing my set list and getting creative with it. It’s so fun, building a set around your favourite songs. How did you choose the line up of songs for this concert? I have a very long playlist of songs that I would love to sing at some point, … More INTERVIEW – LUCIE JONES
  • TWO STRANGERS (CARRY A CAKE ACROSS NEW YORK) – REVIEW – CRITERION THEATRE
    What happens when two strangers, both lacking something in life, carry a cake across New  York? If this production is anything to go by, there is one simple answer – MAGIC!  This gorgeous production, originally performed at the Kiln Theatre last December, places the  audience in the heart of New York, ‘the city of dreams’. It follows the chaotic 48 hours of Robin and Dougal, two strangers whose stories are connected by a wedding, as they do various tasks for the bride.   The story, written by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, is exquisitely done, both parodying and celebrating romantic comedies and films set … More TWO STRANGERS (CARRY A CAKE ACROSS NEW YORK) – REVIEW – CRITERION THEATRE

Leave a Reply